In Dragon Age: Inquisition, “Sit in Judgment” is a quest that repeats throughout the game whenever the Inquisition takes someone captive as part of the main storyline or any sidequests. Interacting with the throne in Skyhold will trigger the quest, prompting you to cast judgment over the Inquisition’s prisoners.
Though you will likely already have a prisoner by the time you reach Skyhold, you will need to leave the area and then return in order to prompt the first “Sit in Judgment” quest. For a full list of all judgment choices you can make and the outcomes, we’ve got everything covered right here.
Please note, while the main quests and side quests relating to each prisoner are listed, their capture can also depend on the choices made during those specific quests.
Chief Movran the Under Judgment Choices
Captured via Side Quest: Lost Souls
Arm and banish him to Tevinter. (Becomes an Agent)
- Greatly Approve: Iron Bull
- Approves: sera
- Slightly Approves: Solas, Dorian, Vivienne, Blackwall, and Cole
- Movran becomes an Agent for Cullen
- The war table operation “Judgment: Movran’s Arrived!” becomes available
- Chasind Throne unlocked
Assign him to Abernache. (Becomes an Agent) — Available if you sided with the templars and Abernaches survived “Champions of the Just”
- Approves: Sera and Iron Bull
- Slightly Approves: Cole and Varric
- Slightly Disapproves: Vivienne
- Movran becomes an Agent for Cullen
- The war table operation “Judgment: Abernache over Under” becomes available
- Chasind Throne unlocked
Place him in a gibbet.
- Slightly Disapproves: Iron Bull, Sera, Cole, and Solas
- Chasind Throne unlocked
Drive them out of your lands.
- Slightly Approves: Sera
- Slightly Disapproves: Iron Bull and Solas
- Disapproves: Cole
- Chasind Throne unlocked
Knight-Captain Denam Judgment Choices
Captured via Main Quest: Champions of the Just (Accessible if you sided with the Templars)
He dies for this. — Available if you open the locked for to his quarters and found the Knight-Vigilant’s body
- Approves: Solas, Iron Bull, Sera, and Cole
- Slightly Approves: Cassandra
Question and then jail him.
- Slightly Approves: Iron Bull, Varric, and Solas
Let the templars judge him.
- Approves: Cole and Iron Bull
- Slightly Approves: Cassandra, Sera, Vivienne, Solas, and Varic
Traditionally he’s exiled. — Available with History Knowledge Inquisition Perk
- Approves: Iron Bull and Cassandra
- Slightly Approves: Blackwall, Sera, Cole, and Solas
I’m Conscripting him. — Available if you did not enter the locked quarters
- Approves: Blackwall
- Slightly Approves: Sera
- Disapproves: Cassandra, Solas, Varric, and Cole
- The war table operation “Judgment: Denam’s Red Templar Patrols” becomes available
Magister Gereon Alexius Judgment Choices
Captured via Main Quest: In Hushed Whispers (Accessible if you sided with the Mages)
I’m executing him myself.
- Approves: Cole and Iron Bull approve
- Slightly Approves: Sera
- Slight Disapproves: Solas and Varric
- Disapproves: Dorian
Imprison him.
- Approves: Iron Bull
- Disapproves: Cole
He’ll serve Redcliffe’s Mages.
- Approves: Solas and Cole
- Slightly Approves: Blackwall, Dorian, and Iron Bill (Dorian’s approval can change based on your following conversation choices.)
- Slightly Disapproves: Sera
Make him harmless. A Tranquil. — Available if you are a Mage Inquisitor
- Approves: Iron Bull
- Slightly Approves: Cassandra
- Disapproves: Blackwall and Cole
- Greatly Disapproves: Solas and Dorian
- Negative impact on your relationship with the Mages if you sided with them after the rebellion
- The war table operation “Judgment: How Could You” becomes available if this is the first time you order someone to be made Tranquil.
I want him researching magic. (Becomes an Agent) — Available with the Arcane Knowledge Inquisition Perk
- Approves: Dorian and Solas approve (Dorian’s approval can change based on your following conversation choices.)
- Slightly Approves: Vivienne, Cole, and Iron Bull
- Slightly Disapproves: Cassandra
- Disapproves: Sera
- Alexius becomes an Agent for Leliana
- The war table operation “Judgment: The Magic Used in Redcliffe” becomes available
Crassius Servis Judgment Choices
Captured via Side Quest: The Trouble with Darkspawn
Give him back to Corypheus.
- Slightly Approves: Solas and Iron Bull
- Disapproves: Cole
An informant. On probation. (Becomes an Agent)
- Approves: Iron Bull and Solas
- Slightly Approves: Vivienne and Blackwall
- Slightly Disapproves: Sera, Dorian, and Cassandra
- Disapproves: Cole
- Servis becomes an Agent for Leliana
- The war table operation “Judgment: Recover Sold Artifacts” becomes available
I want him as a smuggler. (Becomes an Agent) — Available with the Arcane Underworld Inquisition Perk
- Approves: Solas
- Slightly Approves: Varric, Dorian, and Iron Bull
- Slightly Disapproves: Sera, Cassandra, and Cole
- Servis becomes an Agent for the Inquisition (though never appears in the Perk list like other Agents)
Throw him in jail.
- Slightly Approves: Iron Bull and Solas
- Disapproves: Cole
Mayor Gregory Dedrick Judgment Choices
Captured via Side Quest: The Trouble with Darkspawn
I’ll give him a clean death.
- Approves: Sera, Iron Bull, and Cole
- Disapproves: Solas
- Fereldan Throne Unlocked
The best I can do is exile.
- Approves: Solas
- Slightly Approves: Cole
- Slightly Disapproves: Sera and Iron Bull
- Fereldan Throne Unlocked
Ferelden can lock him up.
- Slightly Approves: Vivienne, Varric, and Iron Bull
- Slightly Disapproves: Cole
- Fereldan Throne Unlocked
Give him to the Grey Wardens. — Available after Here Lies the Abyss providing the Gray Wardens were not exiled
- Slightly Approves: Iron Bull, Sera, Cole, and Blackwall
- Slightly Disapproves: Solas and Vivienne
- Fereldan Throne Unlocked
Magister Livius Erimond Judgment Choices
Captured via Main Quest: Here Lies the Abyss
A mage’s punishment. Tranquil. — Available if you are a Mage Inquisitor
- Approves: Iron Bull and Vivienne
- Slightly Approves: Cassandra
- Disapproves: Cole, Blackwall, Dorian, and Solas
- Negative impact on your relationship with the Mages if you sided with them after the rebellion
- The war table operation “Judgment: How Could You” becomes available if this is the first time you order someone to be made Tranquil.
He dies by my sword.
- Approves: Iron Bull, Solas, Sera, and Cole
Give him to the Wardens. Available only if the Grey Wardens were not exiled
- Approves: Blackwall and Iron Bull
- Slightly Approves: Cole and Sera
- Slightly Disapproves: Solas
Jail him and lose the key.
- Slightly Approves: Varric, Dorian, Vivienne, Sera, and Blackwall
- Slightly Disapproves: Solas
- Disapproves: Cole
Ser Ruth Judgment Choices
Captured via Main Quest: Here Lies the Abyss
I won’t Judge a Warden. — Available only if the Grey Wardens were not exiled
- Approves: Iron Bull and Sera
- Slightly Approves: Blackwall
- Slightly Disapproves: Cassandra, Cole, and Vivienne
- Disapproves: Solas
Go to the Deep roads.
- Approves: Sera and Iron Bull
- Slightly Approves: Cole and Varric
- Slightly Disapproves: Solas
- The war table operation “Judgment: The The Death of Good Ser Ruth” becomes available
Public Humiliation, then.
- Approves: Solas and Vivienne
- Disapproves: Sera, Blackwall, and Cole
Exile, like the other Wardens. — Available only if the Grey Wardens were exiled
- Approves: Iron Bull and Solas
- Slightly Disapproves: Sera, Cole, and Iron Bull
Jail her; Throw Away the Key.
- Slightly Approves: Dorian and Cole
- Slightly Disapproves: Sera, Iron Bull, and Solas
Andraste Forgives You. — Available to faithful Inquisitors only
- Approves: Cole and Iron Bull
- Slightly approves: Cassandra, Blackwall, and Sera
- Disapproves: Solas
- The war table operation “Judgment: The Good Works of Ser Ruth” becomes available
Grand Duchess Florianne de Chalons (Alive) Judgment Choices
Captured via Main Quest: Wicked Eyes and Wicked Hearts
Let her repent in a cloister. — Available to faithful Inquisitors only
- Approves: Cole
- Slightly Approves: Cassandra
- Slightly Disapproves: Iron Bull and Solas
Put her guile to work for us!
- Greatly Approves: Solas
- Approves: Iron Bull
- Slightly Disapproves: Vivienne, Cassandra, and Varric
- Disapproves: Sera and Cole
- Florianne becomes an Agent for the Inquisition (though never appears in the Perk list like other Agents)
- The war table operation “Judgment: Playing to Win” becomes available
Common work with the common.
- Approves: Cole, Blackwall, and Sera
- Slightly Approves: Iron Bull and Vivienne
- Disapproves: Solas
Jester’s outfit. Bad shoes.
- Approves: Sera
- Slightly Approves: Dorian and Vivienne
- Slightly Disapproves: Cassandra
- Florianne appears as a jester in the Skyhold throne room
Exile. Out of my sight.
- Slightly Disapproves: Sera, Blackwall, and Cole
Grand Duchess Florianne de Chalons (Dead) Judgment Choices
Captured via Main Quest: Wicked Eyes and Wicked Hearts
My decision is to ignore this.
- Approves: Iron Bull
- Slightly Approves: Sera
- Slightly Disapproves: Cassandra
Ha! Community service! (Becomes an Agent)
- Approves: Varric, Dorian, and Sera
- Slightly Disapproves: Cassandra and Cole
- Florianne’s corpse becomes an Agent for Josephine
- The war table operation “Judgment: Duchess in a Box Tour 9:41” becomes available
Fine, let’s get this over with.
- No effect.
There’s a precedent. — Available with the History Knowledge Inquisition Perk
- Approves: Vivienne and Solas
Captain Thom Rainier Judgment Choices
Captured via Side Quest: Revelations
You’re free, if you atone.
- Greatly Approves: Blackwall
- Approves: Sera
- Blackwall remains in your party as Thom Rainier
The Wardens will decide.
- Greatly Approves: Blackwall (This can change based on your following conversation choices.)
- Slightly Approves: Sera
- Blackwall remains with the Inquisition until Corypheus is defeated, then is handed over to the Grey Wardens
I own you. Your lie continues.
- Disapproves: Sera
- Greatly Disapproves: Blackwall
- Blackwall remains with the Inquisition and continues to pretend to be a Warden
Mistress Poulin Judgment Choice
Captured via Side Quest: Rocky Rescue
You’re free to go.
- Slightly Approves: Blackwall and Varric
- Slightly Disapproves: Iron Bull and Sera
- Orlesian Throne unlocked
Put her to work.
- Approves: Cole
- Slightly Approves: Cassandra, Sera, Cole, Solas, Varric, and Blackwall
- Orlesian Throne unlocked
I’m taking your money. — Available if you are a human noble Inquisitor
- Slightly Disapproves: Cassandra, Blackwall, and Iron Bull
- Disapproves: Solas, Cole, and Varric
- Orlesian Throne unlocked
- Gain a small amount of gold
Treason deserves death.
- Approves: Iron Bull
- Slightly Approves: Solas and Cassandra
- Disapproves: Varric, Blackwall, and Cole
- Orlesian Throne unlocked
Have her rebuild the town. — Available if you have completed the sidequest “Quarry Quandry”
- Greatly Approves: Cole
- Approves: Cassandra, Varric, Blackwall, and Sera
- Slightly Approves: Vivienne and Solas
- Slightly Disapproves: Iron Bull
- Orlesian Throne unlocked
- The war table operation “Judgment: Help the People of Sahrnia” becomes available
Samson Judgment Choices
Captured via Main Quest: What Pride Had Wrought (If you sided with the mages and completed In Hushed Whispers)
Cullen will question you. — Available only if you previously chose “Maddox respected you” as a dialogue option and completed Cullen’s sidequest “Before the Dawn”
- Approves: Iron Bull, Cole, and Solas
- Slightly Approves: Blackwall and Vivienne
Let Kirkwall have you.
- Approves: Varric
Dagna will study your powers.
- Approves: Solas
- Slightly Approves: Varric and Sera
- Slightly Disapproves: Dorian
- Various Corrupting Runes obtained
Shove this coward in a hole.
- Slightly Approves: Sera
- Disapproves: Cole
Exile him to the wilderness.
- Slightly Disapproves: Cole, Varric, and Iron Bull
- Disapproves: Solas
Storvacker Judgment Choices (DLC)
Captured in DLC: Jaws of Hakkon Wrought (Storvacker Caged, Guests of the Hold, and Hakkon Wintersbreath must be completed beforehand.)
Cut back on her treats?
- No effect.
We’ll “bear” her misconduct.
- No effect.
I’m recruiting her.
- Storvacker becomes an Agent for Cullen
- The war table operation “Judgment: Too Grizzly To Bear” becomes available
This is punishment enough.
- No effect.
Tranquil-bear?
- No effect.
Next: Dragon Age: Inquisition – Guide To Completing A Nightmare Difficulty Playthrough
- Guides
- Dragon Age: Inquisition
Meg appreciates gaming on all formats but primarily spends her time achievement hunting to the extreme. Her passion for gaming began as a child when first introduced to the Amstrad.
Source: Read Full Article